Disclaimer: This blog post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of these links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support my work and allows me to continue providing valuable content. Thank you for your support!
Pacifiers are a lifesaver for babies and parents, especially those fussy little ones. Pacifiers help babies satisfy their natural sucking reflex but also help them in their comfort between feedings. Finding one that not only supports your breastfeeding journey but keeps the baby happy may be a little hard, especially with new parents.
Babies Parent comes to help with the list of the top 10 best pacifiers for breastfed babies on the market in 2024. Everything is here, from pacifiers that mimic the breast to those designed for soothing teething pain and even uniquely designed pacifiers. Let’s start the list with some best pacifiers overall.
Best Pacifiers For Breastfed Babies Overall
You can’t go wrong with one of these best pacifiers for breastfed babies. They are all of good quality and have received several positive reviews from customers. Proper pacifiers can smooth the kids, restrict nipple confusion, as well as make it easier to transfer to use baby bottles later.
Nanobebe Silicone Pacifiers For Babies
Product Information
- Brand: Nanobebe
- Material: 100% Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–36 months
- Dishwasher Safe: Yes – Only on top rack
- Price: $5.49/pack of 2 ($2.74 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Soft, skin-like silicone mimics breastfeeding ✅Ergonomic design fits snugly on the baby’s face ✅One-piece design ✅Safe material – BPA and phthalate-free ✅Orthodontic shape supports oral development ✅Easy to clean and sterilize | ❌Clear design makes it easy to lose ❌Lack of a loop for attaching a pacifier clip. |
Nanobebe Silicone Pacifiers For Babies is highly ranked for the safe and soft 100% silicone material that emulates the skin and gives the feeling of breastfeeding. The pacifier’s ergonomic design sits gently below the nose and against the chin, providing a secure fit during use.
One of the major plus sides of this pacifier is that it’s made from one piece of seamless silicone, which is in line with the safety recommendations of the American Academy of Pediatrics. This product is free from BPA and phthalates to provide a healthy and safe option for your baby. Parents appreciate that it is very easy to clean and can be used in dishwashers, baby washers, and sterilizers.
The added orthodontic design on the Nanobebe pacifier will stimulate healthy oral development and be a great long-term investment for your baby. Unfortunately, the pacifier is transparent and, therefore, very easy to lose, especially during nighttime. There is no built-in loop also to attach a pacifier holder, so this might be slightly more challenging to keep tabs on.
Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Pacifiers
Product Information
- Brand: AVENT
- Material: Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–18 months
- Dishwasher Safe: Yes
- Price: $8.94 – $11.29/pack of 4 ($2.23 – $2.82 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Safe silicone material ✅Orthodontic design supports healthy oral development ✅One-piece design ✅Easy for cleaning ✅Compatible with the Philips Avent snuggle plush toy ✅Convenient 4-pack for multiple backups. | ❌Slightly firm ❌Not suitable for very young babies ❌May fall out of the mouth of babies ❌Some babies don’t like the shape ❌Babies can stick their fingers in the hole |
Philips Avent Soothie Orthodontic Pacifiers are made from 100% medical-grade silicone, providing a soft, gentle, durable solution for soothing little ones. They have an orthodontic design with a symmetrical nipple that promotes healthy oral development. Besides, one-piece construction added another layer of safety by eliminating any risk of detaching small parts.
One of the special features of Philip Avent is the finger-held design. A parent can place his or her finger inside the nipple and create a closer association with his or her baby. The pacifiers are also compatible with the Philips Avent Snuggle, a soft, cuddly toy that will help babies love and hang onto their pacifier. Another practical advantage is that this pacifier is really easy to clean. Water never really gets trapped inside the nipple because of its design. This makes sterilizing or putting them in the dishwasher quite easy.
On the downside, some parents have remarked that the material is somewhat firm. Hence, it can easily fall out of the baby’s mouth and is not suitable for babies under 3 months. If they happen to roll onto it, he may be hurt. It is also reported that the baby’s fingers can stuck in the hole.
Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Baby Pacifiers
Product Information
- Brand: Itzy Ritzy
- Material: Rubber
- Recommended Age: 0–6 months
- Dishwasher Safe: No
- Price: $8.99/pack of 2 ($2.49 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Cherry-shaped nipple mimics breastfeeding ✅Large air holes for better airflow and comfort ✅Lightweight design ✅Come in stylish with chic colors | ❌Feel less premium ❌Water can get trapped inside the nipple ❌May not be as soft as expected |
Itzy Ritzy Natural Rubber Baby Pacifiers are special with their cherry-shaped nipple. This special design helps breastfed babies transition smoothly between nursing and pacifier use. Large air holes in the shield allow good ventilation, while a cable-style handle adds style. Importantly, these pacifiers satisfy ASTM safety requirements and contain no BPA or PVC. This can provide parents peace of mind about their baby’s safety.
This set features 2 pacifiers in coordinating colors, making it a functional and fashionable accessory for your baby. These pacifiers are lightweight, which prevents them from falling out of your baby’s mouth – a feature many parents appreciate. However, some users have mentioned that the pacifier does seem a little “cheap” due to the lightweight plastic, but it seems to be durable during use. Water can also be trapped inside the nipple while cleaning it, although it dries off very fast.
Best Breast-Like Pacifiers For Babies
Choosing a pacifier that mimics the breast can make a big difference. The breast-like pacifier will provide comfort and is very similar in form and softness to the mom’s nipple. Thus, this makes it easier on the babies when transitioning between breastfeeding and pacifiers.
Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier
Product Information
- Brand: Tommee Tippee
- Material: Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–6 months
- Dishwasher Safe: Yes – Only on top rack
- Price: $15.44/pack of 4 ($3.86 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Breast-shaped nipple mimics natural breastfeeding ✅Symmetrical design ensures correct placement ✅Available in 2 age stages (0-6 months, 6-18 months) | ❌Heavy for younger infants to hold ❌May fall out of babies’ mouths during sleep due to the weight ❌Quite expensive |
Tommee Tippee Breast-Like Pacifier is one of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, featuring a soft, breast-shaped nipple. Its symmetrical design ensures that the pacifier is always appropriately positioned in your baby’s mouth. The pacifier also has air holes in the shield to improve airflow and prevent skin irritation.
Tommee Tippee pacifiers are available in two stages, 0-6 months and 6-18 months. Its soft, resilient silicone substance and one-piece construction make it simple to clean and sanitary. Many parents appreciate the pacifier’s gentle feel and quality. However, the pacifier’s weight may be a bit heavy for younger babies, causing it to fall out of their mouths more easily, particularly during sleep.
Dr. Brown’s Happy Paci Silicone Pacifier
Product Information
- Brand: Dr. Brown
- Material: Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–6 months
- Dishwasher Safe: Yes – Only on top rack
- Price: $4.59/pack of 3 ($1.53 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Mimics nipple shape ✅Butterfly-shaped shield with air holes provides comfort ✅Soft silicone is gentle on gums ✅Open-back design allows for easy soothing ✅Affordable price | ❌Attract fuzz and hair ❌May be a little large to use for smaller babies |
Dr. Brown’s Happy Paci Silicone Baby Pacifier is thoughtfully designed with a 100% silicone construction for babies from 0 to 6 months. The pacifier’s one-piece structure and butterfly-shaped cover allow it to easily curve away from the baby’s face, which is a terrific feature. It leaves much room for the nose, cheeks, and chin, therefore minimizing any irritations to the skin of the baby. Ventilation holes are also provided in the shield that allows better airflow, preventing the building of moisture and irritation on sensitive babies’ skin.
Parents particularly enjoy the wide base, triangle slope, and soft silicone substance. All characteristics resemble a natural breastfeeding experience. The open-back design lets parents insert their fingers into the nipple to help soothe fussy babies and enhance bonding time. Some parents have said that the pacifier tends to attract fuzz and hair, hence you need to clean it frequently. Cleaning is easy, dishwasher (top rack), and the compatibility of sterilizers make things more straightforward.
Best Pacifiers For Breastfed Babies With Unique Design
Many parents like to use dark-glowing pacifiers for convenience at night. Take a look at some suggestions below for some special designs of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.
MAM Glow-In-Dark Pacifiers For Breastfed Babies
Product Information
- Brand: MAM
- Material: Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–6 months
- Dishwasher Safe: No
- Price: $6.99/pack of 2 ($3.49 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Glow in the dark ✅Soft silicone material ✅BPA-free & BPS-free ✅Come with a self-sterilizing case | ❌Water may become stuck in the nipple after cleaning ❌Not safe for dishwasher |
MAM Glow-In-The-Dark Pacifiers For Breastfed Babies are very convenient for parents to locate them in the dark of night without having to turn on any lights. The silicone nipple is very close to a breast, which makes the baby’s move from nursing to the use of pacifiers quite easy. They also come with a self-sterilizing case for easy cleaning and maintenance, great for busy parents on the go.
While the majority of parents adore the glowing effect and resilience, some stated that while cleaning, water can be trapped inside the nipple. It is also not safe to put this MAM pacifier in the dishwasher. However, this small inconvenience couldn’t deprive the pacifier of its very high quality and functionality.
Chicco PhysioForma One-Piece Pacifier
Product Information
- Brand: Chicco
- Material: Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–6 months
- Dishwasher Safe: No
- Price: $11.15/pack of 4 ($2.78 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Supports natural breathing ✅Extra-soft, satin-textured silicone nipple ✅Large ventilation holes prevent skin irritation ✅BPA and latex-free for added safety ✅Comes with a sterilizer case | ❌Silicone material attracts fuzz, lint, and hair ❌Not safe for dishwasher |
Chicco PhysioForma One-Piece Pacifier is designed to support natural breathing and comfort for the baby. Constructed of extra-soft, satin-textured silicone, this pacifier emulates the softness of the breast while ensuring a secure and slip-resistant fit. The innovative shape also has a lateral curve on the nipple. This helps to distribute pressure on the palate effectively, thus encouraging healthy tongue movement.
It has large ventilation holes to prevent the buildup of saliva around your baby’s mouth, which can irritate. Parents will also appreciate that this is made of materials that are free of BPA and latex to ensure the safety of their small child. The Chicco pacifier comes with a storage case, which allows you to have quick and easy sterilization. Some parents also complained of fuzz or hair sticking onto the pacifier due to the silicone material.
NUK Comfy Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers
Product Information
- Brand: NUK
- Material: Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–6 months
- Dishwasher Safe: Yes – Only on top rack
- Price: $6.17/pack of 5 ($1.23 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Heart-shaped shield allows for easy breathing ✅100% medical-grade silicone ✅Easy to clean with no water trapped in the nipple ✅Durable, one-piece construction ✅Very affordable price | ❌Silicone material easily attracts hair, lint, and dust. |
NUK Orthodontic Baby Pacifiers are one of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, especially newborn babies since they naturally fit the design against a baby’s palate. The heart-shaped shield fits securely under the baby’s nose, allowing unobstructed breathing. These pacifiers are made from 100% medical-grade silicone, ensuring safety and comfort. Many reviews comment on how these pacifiers last quite long and are easy to sterilize by either boiling or just generally washing them out with hot water.
The only general gripe that most parents have, however, is that the silicone material seems to attract hair, lint, and dust. Especially when the pacifiers come in contact with blankets or any soft surface. That is somewhat frustrating, but it’s easily remedied with frequent rinsing.
Best Pacifiers For Teething Babies
It is important to pick up the right pacifier for a teething baby. The best pacifiers intended for teething babies come in soft and strong materials to resist biting and gnawing while giving relief. Often, such pacifiers double as teethers that will help your baby stay comfortable and relaxed during this milestone.
Ryan & Rose Cutie Silicone Pacifier For Teething
Product Information
- Brand: Ryan & Rose
- Material: Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–24 months
- Dishwasher Safe: Yes
- Price: $19.99/pack of 5 ($3.99 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Pacifier and teether in one ✅Made from 100% medical-grade silicone ✅Comfortable teether handle ✅Durable and easy to clean ✅Neutral colors with a stylish design | ❌The handle is not moveable ❌Quite expensive |
Ryan & Rose Cutie Silicone Pacifier For Teething is versatile, suitable for both pacifier and teether use to help soothe babies in their teething stage. It comes in a variety pack starter kit bag that lets your baby try 5 different styles. It is made from 100% medical-grade silicone, which makes it safe yet durable, and the one-piece construction reduces the risk of small parts breaking off. The teether handle is just right for babies to easily grasp and hold.
This pacifier-teether hybrid earns extra points for its stylish design, replete with neutral colors and aesthetic appeal. Parents praise its durability, ease of cleaning, and resilience to heavy use and even boiling for sterilization. While the non-moveable handle does take up a bit more space, it’s well worth it for the comfort and relief it brings to teething babies.
Smily Mia Penguin Pacifier For Teether
Product Information
- Brand: Smily Mia
- Material: Silicone
- Recommended Age: 0–12 months
- Dishwasher Safe: Yes
- Price: $12.99/pack of 2 ($6.49 for each)
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅Wearable design ✅Super soft silicone mimics natural feeding ✅Lightweight, easy for babies to grasp and manage. ✅Dishwasher safe and easy to clean | ❌Silicone material easily attracts lint, hair, and pet hair ❌Most expensive |
Smily Mia Penguin Pacifier For Teether is a game changer for parents whose babies just refuse to take to traditional pacifiers. The wearable teether stays secure on the baby’s wrist, minimizing the chances of falling off and thus always remaining within easy reach.
This teether is made of soft yet sturdy silicone, which will be kind on sensitive gums. Parents love how this product is easy to clean, portable, and able to withstand the test of time. Others warn it tends to gather lint or hair in a short time. You have to be careful once the pacifier drops to the floor if you have pets in the house.
When Should Parents Introduce Pacifiers To The Baby?
Parents can introduce their baby to a pacifier when the breastfeeding pattern has been well established, usually at 3 to 4 weeks. That way, it will not interfere with the feeding routine or create problems, like nipple confusion. If bottle feeding, pacifiers can be introduced sooner. Always pay close attention to the response of the baby when using a pacifier for best safety.
When Should A Baby Stop Using Pacifier?
Babies should stop using pacifiers at 2 to 4 years old to avoid further dental problems and speech developmental delays. Gradual weaning at such times eases the transition and ensures that oral and emotional development remains on track.
Final Thoughts
The 10 best pacifiers for breastfed babies on this list offer great options for parents in 2024. Soft pacifiers made from safe materials will provide comfort for both caregivers and babies. Parents just need to remember to regularly clean the pacifier (sterilize or boil in water) to ensure hygiene.
