In the first few months of babies, you must deal with a huge number of diapers and the annoying smell. That’s why such disposable diapers need a specialized diaper pail to keep your space odorless. There are various choices on the market that make you confused, so I came up with a comparison between 2 popular options: Ubbi Diaper Pail vs Diaper Genie.
Ubbi Diaper Pail vs Diaper Genie comparison in details
We will focus on their functionality, durability, design, cost, and capacity.
Functionality
What makes diaper pails different from normal trash bins? The answer is odor-fighting ability. So we will focus on that.
The Diaper Genie is designed with a double airtight clamp to lock the odor inside. An antimicrobial carbon filter is also added to prevent bacteria and the annoying smell. And it is great that without actually touching the Diaper Genie with your hand, you can still operate it. You just need to simply take a step on the foot pedal, then the lid opens for you to drop the diaper into a trap door.
Regarding the Ubbi Pail, sleek steel with rubber seals keeps the smell inside very well. However, you need to use your hand to slide a small door on the top of the pail open, then throw the dirty diaper. The tongue may not move smoothly, it easily becomes sticky after a time and requires strong, forceful pushing to open. It is not a hands-free design. And the Ubbi is not designed with a double clamp system like the Diaper Genie, so some smell may escape outside when you open the door.
In the functionality of Diaper Genie vs Ubbi Diaper Pail, the first one seems to be the winner.
Durability
The Diaper Genie is made of durable plastic, which is lighter but may have a shorter life span. It can be prone to cracking or breaking, especially with a heavy amount of diapers.
The Ubbi Pail is made of sleek steel with rubber seals. That makes it heavier but more durable and resistant to odors, sturdy, and less likely to be cracked or broken after a time of being used.
In terms of pail durability, the Ubbi Pail clearly wins due to its steel construction.
Design
The Standard Diaper Genie collection offers 5 solid colors: pink, white, gray, green, and blue. Meanwhile, you can diversify your options by considering the Diaper Genie Expressions collection which has a slightly different shape, like gray cloth, pink starburst, blue knit, green twinkle, and white/pink tile. Additionally, you can decorate the pail as you like using interchangeable fabric sleeves with various designs, which are sold separately.
The Ubbi Pail, in general, is modern-looking, sleek and polished. The options are diverse with 12 finishes, even with wood grain, rose gold, or marble.
If you are looking for a minimal and modern diaper pail, Ubbi is suitable. Or else, if you prefer decoration and flexibility, Diaper Genie is a good choice.
Cost
Both Ubbi Diaper Pail and Diaper Genie can be ordered online or at major retailers. The Diaper Genie and the Diaper Genie Expressions are much more affordable than the Ubbi Pail.
The Standard Diaper Genie costs $36.99 and The Genie Expressions costs $24.99, along with the fabric covers price around $6-$10. The Ubbi Diaper Pail costs around $72, doubling that of Genie.
The price differentiation has a reason behind it. For Diaper Genie, a specific refill scented bag that costs $20 for each three-pack is a must. Meanwhile, the Ubbi can be refilled with any garbage bag available at your home. So, the Diaper Genie is a winner in the short term, but the Ubbi actually offers you a bargain in the long run.
Capacity
Like baby clothes, the number of diapers is much more than you can imagine. Therefore, the capacity of diaper pails should be considered carefully.
The Diaper Genie looks smaller than the Ubbi Diaper Pail, and its trash bag is even smaller. The Diaper Genie is estimated to have enough room for 15 diapers per bag. And the Ubbi Diaper Pail has space enough for up to 30 diapers.
Incapacity comparison, the Ubbi wins!
Additional features
Diaper Genie is awesome in fighting odor, with a specific scented trash bag design, and an inner lid at the top of the pail to close the bag as soon as the outer lid is closed. The trash bag can be costly in the long run but really worth it somehow.
Ubbi Diaper Pail vs Diaper Genie comparison in a nutshell
In general, comparing Ubbi Diaper Pail vs Diaper Genie, the Ubbi is considered the better option, regarding durability, long-term cost, and capacity. However, it would be great if Ubbi could improve its current design into hands-free, then it totally win this battle.
Conclusion
In short, the Ubbi Steel cannot beat the Diaper Genie in terms of odor fighting and hands-free operation. In other aspects regarding long-term cost and durability, the Ubbi Steel is absolutely the winner.
If you are thinking about an affordable option, choose Ubbi Steel. If your budget is higher, Diaper Genie should be considered due to its optimal odor containing.
